Jimmy Wales Weighs in on Flagged Revisions
My post this weekend made a point of separating uninformed Wikipedia criticism from informed Wikipedia criticism. One that I listed as meriting a response was the weirdly-titled article "Where Wikipedia Ends" by Farhad Manjoo in Time. In fact, only a day later Wikipedia co-founder and (these days mostly) spiritual leader Jimmy Wales took on the hype at Huffington Post. Here's the core of his response:
[M]aybe you read this story on Time.com: "They recently instituted a major change, imposing a layer of editorial control on entries about living people. In the past, only articles on high-profile subjects like Barack Obama were protected from anonymous revisions. Under the new plan, people can freely alter Wikipedia articles on, say, their local officials or company head -- but those changes will become live only once they've been vetted by a Wikipedia administrator."
That's all very interesting, albeit completely untrue.
Imagine if the stories told instead said things like this:
"In a major shift towards greater openness, Wikipedia is taking the first steps towards doing away with controls that kept certain pages 'protected' or 'locked' for many years. Previously, certain high profile and high risk biographies and other entries were kept locked to prevent vandalism by users who had not registered accounts on the site for a 'waiting period' of 4 days."
"The new feature, long advocated by the site's founder Jimmy Wales, eliminates that restriction by allowing anyone to edit these pages, even without logging in. The secret to being able to do this is that the new feature creates a queue where tens of thousands of longtime users of the site can approve these changes - changes that were previously completely forbidden."
What? Really? The solution to the problem of bad speech is actually more speech? Openness and collaboration actually work?
Nevertheless, it is true. English Wikipedia will soon launch a new feature that will allow you to edit, as an inexperienced user, articles that have previously been locked more-or-less continuously for years.
To read more about flagged revisions, see Flagged Revisions Come to the English Wikipedia.